Read this page as Markdown
Gumshoe versus Waikay, a detailed comparison buyers guide

AI visibility tools, head to head

Gumshoe vs Waikay

Pricing, features and differences. Prices, plans and developer access checked November 2026.

Gumshoe and Waikay both help teams track how AI models describe, recommend, and cite brands. Buyers often compare them when they need a clearer view of brand visibility across ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, Perplexity, and other AI search tools. The main differences come down to how each platform gathers insights and guides next steps. Gumshoe centers on persona-based buyer conversations across 11 AI models, then connects visibility, competitor, citation, content, and technical findings to actions. Waikay takes an entity-first approach that checks AI-generated claims, flags errors, compares competitors, and prioritizes content and authority work. This comparison looks at AI model coverage, monitoring methods, competitor research, citation and entity analysis, recommended actions, and fit for in-house teams and agencies.

At a glance

Gumshoe

Pick it if persona-generated prompts suit how you work, keeping in mind the entry plan is 80 prompts a month and there is no trial.

Entry price
$99/mo
Tracked prompts
80/mo - 8 personas × 10 prompts
Free trial
No trial - 1 free sample audit

Waikay

Pick it if you want an entity graph behind the analysis, and read the $24.95 tier as a way in rather than the plan you stay on.

Entry price
$24.95/mo
Tracked prompts
40 prompts/week at $24.95; 120 / 360 above; extras purchasable
Free trial
None - free plan instead

Hi, MooseOur AEO tool

Pick it if you want the fix shipped rather than scored: an agent that publishes the change, audio repurposing no other tool here offers at any price, and a built-in model so the AI can cost you nothing.

Entry price
$39/mo BYOK; $79/mo AI included
Tracked prompts
No hard limit on any plan
Free trial
n/a - free plan, no expiry

Where Gumshoe and Waikay differ

Of the 202 rows in the full comparison, these are the 15 where one tool says yes and the other says no. Gumshoe has 8 that Waikay lacks, and Waikay has 7 that Gumshoe lacks.

Rows where Gumshoe and Waikay give opposite answers, with Hi, Moose alongside. Researched August 2026; MCP and API rows checked November 2026.
Feature Gumshoe Waikay Hi, Moose
Gumshoe has it, Waikay does not 8
GrokVisibility & prompt tracking Yes No Yes
DeepSeekVisibility & prompt tracking Yes No Yes
Sentiment scoringScoring & analysis Yes - $299 plan No - deliberately excluded Yes
Page-level AEO auditTaking action (the AEO loop) Yes - 10–50 URLs/mo by plan No Yes
Research-backed briefsContent generation Yes - content plans from audit gaps No - vendor states it does not generate content Yes
Full draft generationContent generation Yes No Yes
Monitored page managementSite crawl & monitoring Yes - audited page list with scores No Yes
In-app help agentPlatform & support Yes - AI chat with human handoff No - live chat with staff Yes
Waikay has it, Gumshoe does not 7
Free plan availablePricing & cost model No - one free sample audit Yes - 3 one-time credits, no card Yes - free forever, no card
Usage metered in one transparent unitPricing & cost model No - separate audit, URL and content caps Yes - credits Yes - AI credits, published rate card
Per-prompt model selectionVisibility & prompt tracking No - set per audit Yes - models and cadence per prompt Yes
Feature-parity / accuracy scoringScoring & analysis No Yes - claim-level check and flag Yes
Site-wide entity graphEntity & knowledge graph No Yes - built from crawled pages Yes
Done-for-you service availablePlatform & support No - agency partner network Yes - entity map managed service Yes
Founders have SEO backgroundsTeam No. Founded in 2025 by Todd Sawicki, previously CEO of ad platform Zemanta, and Patrick O'Donnell, previously a co-founder of Urbanspoon. Yes. Yes. Founder Sam Morris has 15+ years in SEO and software engineering.

What changed since August 2026

Changes each vendor has announced on its own site, checked November 2026.

Gumshoe

  • August 17, 2026New bundles and audits; custom reports dropped.
  • September 3, 2026Technical GEO Audit added.
  • September 10, 2026Citation Audit added.

Waikay

No dated changes found on the vendor's site.

The row SEOs read first

Founders have SEO backgrounds?

A tool built by people who have done the work makes different choices.

Gumshoe

No

No. Founded in 2025 by Todd Sawicki, previously CEO of ad platform Zemanta, and Patrick O'Donnell, previously a co-founder of Urbanspoon.

Waikay

Yes

Yes.

Hi, MooseOur AEO tool

Yes

Yes. Founder Sam Morris has 15+ years in SEO and software engineering.

Full comparison

202 rows across 20 categories. Values are quoted as published; where a vendor does not publish a number, the cell says so.

Feature comparison: Gumshoe, Waikay and Hi, Moose. Price, free plan, trial, prompts, engines, MCP, API and seats checked November 2026. Other rows researched August 2026.
Feature Gumshoe Waikay Hi, Moose Our AEO tool
Pricing & cost model
Free plan available No - one free sample audit Yes - 3 one-time credits, no card Yes - free forever, no card
Free daily visibility runs, no cap No No Yes - local runs unlimited on every plan
Engines free to run daily 0 0 6
Entry paid price $99/mo $24.95/mo $39/mo BYOK; $79/mo AI included
Annual billing discount Not published - monthly only Not published - monthly only Yes - BYOK 2 months free; managed plans ~10%
Pricing model Flat monthly, billed per project Tiered plans + monthly credits Flat plan with monthly AI credit balance, or BYOK
Bring your own API key No No Yes - OpenRouter
Can run with $0 AI cost to vendor No No Yes
Usage metered in one transparent unit No - separate audit, URL and content caps Yes - credits Yes - AI credits, published rate card
In-app usage dashboard Yes - usage tab per workspace Partial - per-prompt cost estimates Yes - % used, reset date, pace warning
Agency / reseller tier Partial - partner discount, no separate plan Partial - agency-oriented tier, no reseller program Yes - $149 BYOK Agency; $449+ AI included
Affiliate program Not published Not published Yes
Annual contract required No No No
Free trial length No trial - 1 free sample audit None - free plan instead n/a - free plan, no expiry
Paid plans pricing range $99–$299/mo + custom $24.95–$449.95/mo + enterprise $39–$1,999/mo
Deployment, privacy & data ownership
Native desktop app No No Yes - Windows and macOS
Browser-based app Yes Yes Yes
Local-first data storage No - cloud SaaS No - cloud SaaS Yes - local database on the device
Works offline No No Partial - local models and stored data; engine checks need the web
On-device AI Inference No No Yes
Local model sizes offered 0 0 3
Data export on cancellation CSV, JSON and API anytime Not published - CSV/JSON while active CSV, PDF, DOCX exports plus full local backup
SOC 2 certification None published Not published Pending
ISO certification None published Not published - UK ICO registered No
Local backup and restore No No - vendor-side only Yes - export and import a backup file
Visibility & prompt tracking
Engines tracked 12 model families; 6 per audit by default 6 10 on AI included plans; 9 on BYOK paid plans; 6 on the free plan
Real consumer-surface capture No - official APIs, interface spot-checks Partial - 4 scraped, 4 via API Yes - 6 engines read from the device, no API
ChatGPT Yes Yes - API and scraped Yes
Claude Yes Yes - API only Yes
Gemini Yes Yes - API and scraped Yes
Google AI Mode Not published Yes - scraped Yes
Google AI Overviews Yes Partial - AI Mode only Yes
Grok Yes No Yes
Bing Copilot Unclear - listed on one page only Yes - scraped Yes - AI included plans
DeepSeek Yes No Yes
Meta AI No No Yes
Tracked prompts included 80/mo - 8 personas × 10 prompts 40 prompts/week at $24.95; 120 / 360 above; extras purchasable No hard limit on any plan
Samples per prompt configurable No - each prompt asked once per model Not published Yes
Run cadence options Monthly audit; weekly or daily snapshots Daily, every 2 days, weekly Multiple times a day, weekly, monthly, and on-demand
On-demand run now Partial - within plan audit limits Yes - report updates Yes
Instant one-off check No - free tools not launched No - project setup required Yes
Prompt manager Partial - generated from personas and topics Yes - topic groups, per-prompt config Yes
Branded vs non-branded classification Not published Partial - knowledge vs commercial split Yes
Prompt categories and topics Yes - topics per prompt Yes - topic clusters and tags Yes
Per-prompt model selection No - set per audit Yes - models and cadence per prompt Yes
Brand name variant support Not published Partial - normalised to parent brand Yes - secondary brand terms
Brand multi-domain support Not published Not published - one URL per project Yes - secondary owned domains
Suggested prompts from Google Search Console No No - no Search Console connection Yes - real GSC questions
Suggested prompts from competitor gaps Partial - persona and topic gaps Yes Yes
Perplexity Yes Yes - API only Yes
Scoring & analysis
Mention detection Yes Yes Yes
Citation detection Yes - URL and domain Yes Yes - domain and page level
Sentiment scoring Yes - $299 plan No - deliberately excluded Yes
Average position / rank Yes - rank per answer Partial - competitor rank, not answer position Yes
Share of Voice Yes - visibility percentage Yes Yes
Share of Mentions Yes - leaderboard mention counts Yes Yes
Share of Citations Partial - source counts, no share metric Partial - citation counts, no share metric Yes
Narrative drift detection Partial - theme and sentiment over runs Partial - claims refresh each report update Yes - scored against a brand truth profile
Feature-parity / accuracy scoring No Yes - claim-level check and flag Yes
Untracked brand extraction Yes - every brand in the answers Yes - competitors auto-detected Yes - with sentiment and average rank
Cited source categorization Yes - $299 plan Yes - knowledge vs commercial Yes - 8 source types
Topic-level breakdown Yes Yes Yes
Engine-level breakdown Yes Yes Yes
Competitor tracking Yes Yes Yes - or promote any brand seen in results
Competitors included Up to 30 2 in reports; auto-detected in prompts 30
Visibility gap analysis Yes - persona, topic and competitor Yes Yes
ChatGPT fan-out capture No No - fan-out used to generate prompts Yes
AI Mode grounding queries capture No Not published Yes - the live grounding searches
Bing Index probe No No Yes
AI crawler access check Yes - per URL Partial - vendor rates it as limited Yes - retrieval, live fetch and training
Reporting & exports
Executive dashboard Yes Yes Yes
AI-written narrative summary Not published Not published Yes
Data export Yes - CSV, JSON, API, share links Yes - CSV, JSON, API Yes - CSV, Excel and API
Branded PDF report No Partial - PDF/PNG export, no custom branding Yes
Scheduled email reports Partial - run-complete emails Not published Yes - paid, per-user opt-in
Action log with export No Partial - claim review status, no export Yes - CSV on paid managed plans
Historical data retention Not published Not published No cap - stored on your device. AI included plans add 365 days of cloud backup; audio analytics 180–365 days
Taking action (the AEO loop)
Covers full loop: track → fix → verify → deploy Partial - no deploy step Partial - no publishing step Yes
Page-level AEO audit Yes - 10–50 URLs/mo by plan No Yes
Scored categories 6 named categories 0 9
Retrieval-readiness scoring Partial - topics grouped by retrieval issue No Yes - deterministic dense retrieval
Evidence tiers on recommendations No - priority ranking only Partial - ranked by impact and effort Yes - proven, directional, best-practice
Element-level rewrite suggestions Partial - page-level content plans Partial - issue list, not rewrites Yes - element, character budget, before and after
Second-model QA pass No Partial - manual paste into Claude or Gemini Yes - pass, revised or needs human review
Static crawler-view snapshot Not published No Yes - full-page screenshot, JavaScript off
Audit input sources Entered URLs + site crawl Site pages crawled, LLM responses Live URL, pasted text, file, WordPress, Webflow, Grav
Baseline vs verification re-runs Yes - score history per page Partial - score history via report updates Yes - compares against the baseline
Recommendation status tracking Not published No - claim review only Yes - planned, staged, completed
Visibility data sets page priority Yes - audit gaps drive recommendations Partial - topic-level, not page-level Yes - defend, recover, convert, earn
Search Console sets page priority No No Yes - protect, balanced or expand
Branded audit PDF No No - unbranded share URL Yes
CMS integration & publishing
WordPress No No Yes - official plugin, production and staging
Webflow No No Yes - OAuth MCP, pages and collection items
Framer No No On roadmap
Grav No No Yes - official plugin
Shopify No No On roadmap
Surgical element-level edits to live page No No Yes
Preview before applying No No Yes
Staging environment support No No Yes - WordPress, with promote to production
One-click rollback No No Yes - WordPress
Patch history per site No No Yes - WordPress
Visual placement picker No No Yes - pick the spot on the rendered page
Push Schema JSON-LD into page No - flags gaps only No - entity files via paid service Yes - FAQPage schema
Publish approval gate n/a - never publishes No Yes - always, including scheduled runs
Agentic capability
Truly agentic (agent chooses its own steps) No No - vendor states no agents Yes - plans and executes against the live web
Fixed-workflow automation only Yes - scheduled audits only Yes - scheduled runs only No - workflows exist alongside the agent
Agents can run on local model at zero cost No No Yes
Multi-agent panel No No Yes - two extra agents, paid plans
Live browser view No No Yes
Take control mid-run No No Yes
Steer agent while running No No Yes - talk to any agent mid-job
Background execution Partial - audits run server-side No - scheduled tracking only Yes - with notify on completion
Approval gate before real-world actions n/a - no real-world actions No - takes no external actions Yes
Long-running deep work jobs No Partial - deeper crawl run takes 5–6 min Yes
Scheduled agent jobs No - scheduled audits, not agents No Yes - daily, weekdays, weekly, monthly
Agent produces saved artifacts No Partial - saved reports and plans Yes - briefs, drafts, FAQs, audits
Evidence capture Partial - full audit transcripts kept Yes - full responses and citations Yes - screenshots and captured proof
Searchable job history Partial - audit run history Partial - report history only Yes
Chat & assistant
Agentic chat with mid-answer tool calls No No - external assistants only, via MCP Yes
Model picker per conversation No No Yes
LLM models available n/a 0 Models from OpenAI, Anthropic, Google, xAI, Meta, Mistral, Moonshot AI and Z.ai, with major releases added soon after launch; local models; any model on BYOK
Chat memory across conversations No No Yes - semantic search over past chats
Live web search No No Yes
Fetch and read URLs Partial - audits URLs you enter No Yes
Semantic search over your own site No - crawl feeds content audit only No Yes - on-device index
Topic coverage check Yes - $299 plan Yes - topic breadth scoring Yes - covered, partial or not covered
File attachments No No Yes - txt, md, doc, docx, pdf, images
In-app screenshot capture No No Yes - screen or window, with crop
Custom specialists with own tool access No No Yes - plus 6 presets
Image generation No No Yes
Content generation
Research-backed briefs Yes - content plans from audit gaps No - vendor states it does not generate content Yes
Live SERP / PAA research No No Yes - plus related searches and AI search snapshots
Full draft generation Yes No Yes
Brand voice grounding Partial - brand voice style toggle No Yes
Brand truth profile Not published Partial - checked and flagged claim list Yes
Internal linking placement Not published No - sister product only Yes
Featured image generation No No Yes
FAQ generation with schema export Partial - FAQ format, no schema export No Yes - HTML and JSON-LD
Key points extraction No - key points are a manual input No Yes - pushable into the live page
AI-tell removal pass No No Yes - paid, toggleable
Artifact library Partial - generated pieces stored per project No Yes
Export formats Not published CSV, JSON, PDF, PNG Markdown, HTML, DOCX, PDF, TXT
Revise artifacts in place Not published No Yes
Deploy directly to CMS No - manual publish No Yes
Content repurposing / audio
Turn any page into audio No No Yes - URL, pasted text or file
Two-voice conversation format No No Yes
Voices 0 0 30
Languages 0 0 24
Length options n/a n/a Short, standard, deep dive
Embeddable audio player No No Yes
Player theming and layout No No Yes - theme, layout, accent, title, transcript
White-label audio attribution No No Yes - agency plans
Attribution backlink to agency No No Yes - real link in page HTML
Listening analytics No No Yes - plays, completion, listen time
BYOK audio generation No No Yes
Site crawl & monitoring
Automatic site discovery Yes - crawls the site for content gaps Yes - top pages crawled at setup Yes
Scheduled full-site crawl Partial - monthly, $299 plan No - crawl runs per report Yes - weekly or on demand
Monitored page management Yes - audited page list with scores No Yes
Batched change digests No No Yes
On-device semantic index No No Yes
Page freshness tracking Partial - audit score history per page No Yes
Entity & knowledge graph
Site-wide entity graph No Yes - built from crawled pages Yes
Inferred relationships Partial - brand and attribute co-mentions Yes Yes
Salience scoring Partial - theme frequency counts Partial - association strength heatmap Yes
Graph readable by AI agent No Partial - entity files via paid service Yes
Graph export No Partial - JSON via paid service Yes - CSV and PDF
Automation & workflows
Visibility-threshold triggers No No Yes - mentions or citations, all or one topic
Pre-built recovery recipe No Partial - prioritised plan, executed manually Yes - detect, locate, audit, stage a fix
Conditional branching No No Partial - branches on whether a matching page exists
Scheduled content cadence No No Yes - daily to monthly
Workflow reports No No Yes - posted to the inbox
Alerts & inbox
Unified project inbox No No Yes
Native OS notifications No No - web only Yes - Windows and macOS
Customized notifications with severity thresholds No Not published Yes - per project
Email digest Partial - audit-complete emails Not published Yes
Teams & workspaces
Seats included Unlimited - no per-seat fee 1 / 2 / unlimited by plan Unlimited on AI included plans; 10 on BYOK Premium, 25 on BYOK Agency
Cost per additional seat $0 Not published - upgrade required $0 on AI included plans, seats are unlimited; BYOK plans include 10 or 25 seats
Shared allowance across team Yes - allowance sits on the project Yes - credits pooled per account Yes
Per-member usage visibility Partial - usage tab, not per member Not published Yes
Multi-project workspaces Yes Yes Yes
Projects included Unlimited; each billed its own plan Unlimited from $69.95 1 free, 3–10 managed, 25–unlimited agency; +$10 each
Archive and restore projects Not published Not published Yes
Per-project API keys Not published No - one account key Yes - rotatable
SSO / SAML Not published Not published Roadmap
Agency & white-label
White-label PDF reports No - stated as roadmap No Yes - visibility report and audit
Custom logo, color and link No No Yes
White-label audio player No No Yes - custom attribution text and link
Client-facing backlink No No Yes
Dedicated agency tier No - partner discount on same plans Partial - agency-oriented tier, no separate program Yes - four tiers
Client sub-accounts Yes - client workspaces, viewer role Partial - unlimited seats and projects, no client roles No - clients are projects, no client logins
Integrations
Google Search Console No No Yes - OAuth, credentials stay on device
Google Analytics No No Roadmap
MCP connector support Yes - plan not confirmed Yes - read-only, 5 tools Yes - hosted server on every plan; works with Claude, ChatGPT, Claude Code, Codex and Cursor
Public API Yes - turned on by request; can start audits Yes - $69.95 and above Yes - REST API on paid plans
Slack No No Yes - through the MCP server, and Microsoft Teams the same way
Zapier No Partial - via API, no native app No
Custom connection support API and exports only Partial - JSON API only Yes - request a connection, paid plans
Platform & support
UI languages 1 (English) Not published - analyses 13–47 languages 6
Troubleshooting and recovery tools Not published Partial - crawler whitelisting docs Yes
In-app help agent Yes - AI chat with human handoff No - live chat with staff Yes
Done-for-you service available No - agency partner network Yes - entity map managed service Yes
Team
Founders have SEO backgrounds No. Founded in 2025 by Todd Sawicki, previously CEO of ad platform Zemanta, and Patrick O'Donnell, previously a co-founder of Urbanspoon. Yes. Yes. Founder Sam Morris has 15+ years in SEO and software engineering.

Which one to pick

For an agency, Gumshoe has client workspaces with a viewer role, and Waikay has no client roles. For an in-house team, Gumshoe suits one that wants audits and drafts, and Waikay suits one that wants accuracy checks. For a solo founder, Waikay starts at $24.95 a month.

Waikay has a read-only MCP server with 5 tools and an API from $69.95 a month. Gumshoe has an MCP connection and an API that it turns on by request. Hi, Moose has an MCP server on every plan and a REST API on paid plans from $39 a month. Waikay does not audit pages or write drafts, and Gumshoe does both. Hi, Moose does both and publishes the change. Waikay is the cheapest of the three to start, at $24.95 a month.

The third option

Both of these tools tell you what happened. Hi, Moose goes and fixes it.

Same visibility data, on your own machine, for $39 a month. Then it writes the change, publishes it, and re-runs the prompts to prove it worked.

No card. BYOK Free stays free.

$39 a month, or nothing at allHi, Moose is $39 a month, and the free tier runs on your own keys with no cap. Gumshoe is $99/mo. Waikay is $24.95/mo.
Your data stays on your machine, backed up if you want itThe app runs on macOS and Windows, so prompts, answers and history sit on your disk. Paid managed plans add cloud backup, so a dead laptop does not cost you your history. Both alternatives are cloud accounts that hold your prompt set.
It fixes the page, not just the chartTrack, fix, verify, deploy. Hi, Moose audits the page, rewrites the elements, previews the change and publishes to WordPress, Webflow or Grav. Neither Gumshoe nor Waikay publishes anything.
A real agent, not a saved reportThe agent picks its own steps, runs in the background, and stops at an approval gate before it touches a live page. You can watch it work and take the wheel mid-run.
Ten engines, six of them read on your computerChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Gemini, Grok, AI Overviews, AI Mode, Copilot, DeepSeek and Meta AI, with branded PDFs, scheduled email and history you keep forever. Copilot is on AI included plans. No per-engine add-ons.
Pages become audio, tooTurn any page into a two-voice audio version with an embeddable player you can white-label for clients. Neither competitor does audio at all.

Sources and research date

Checked November 2026

Price, free plan, trial, prompts, engines, MCP, API and seats were checked against each vendor's own site in November 2026. The other rows were researched in August 2026, and where a vendor's site did not state a fact in November 2026, the August 2026 value stands. Every value comes from vendor pricing pages, public docs or a live account. Where a vendor does not publish a number, the cell says not published instead of an estimate. Plans change often. If a row is wrong, tell us and we will date the correction.

Checked for this pair

  1. 1gumshoe.ai
  2. 2support.gumshoe.ai
  3. 3waikay.io